Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments

14 of the 101 reviews raise this · 9 of them still recommend the game.

“i loved every bit of the game, despite it crashing while loading Kew Gardens (which i only managed to fix by forcing dx9). didnt expect to see half the mechanics here and i definitely didnt expect to actually enjoy all…”

“I enjoyed. It's an old game and sometimes (like Watson always standing in the way in the Kew garden streets) but it plays nicely and I think lockpicking is kind of original and interesting. WARNING: Played on GForce Now…”

“THE AMOUNT OF CRASHES GRRR”

13 of the 101 reviews raise this · 11 of them still recommend the game.

“Genuinely did not expect to enjoy playing dress-up as a Victorian cocaine enthusiast this much, yet there I am, 10 hours later, still accusing random butlers of murder with zero evidence. The deduction system is…”

“weirdly loved this! bought it in a sale and started it up to take a break from twitchy roguelikes and too-big open worlds. its a little janky, a little uneven and it took me way too long to find the button to switch…”

“bad game. you aren't a detective, you press the buttons as the games tells you what to think. crimes and motives don't make sense. you figure out whats going on 10 years before the game tells you. not fun”

8 of the 101 reviews raise this · 5 of them still recommend the game.

“Nothing much to say other than you play as Sherlock Holmes and you are solving a bunch of different cases. It reminded me the most of a classic Sherlock Holmes experience, whilst the other game "Chapter One" served as a…”

“Great addition to the previous games from Frogwares, with Easter Eggs and mentions from the previous cases. I enjoyed it a great deal and it is one of my favourite games. The cases were fun to unravel, the deductions…”

“Although I hated the testimant of sherlock holmes, I really did like this game. I didn't have to use the guide as much and can skip over stupic lockpick puzzles. Overall a pleasant experience.”

5 of the 101 reviews raise this · 5 of them still recommend the game.

“Absolutely loved it. Finished the game in almost 17 hours solving 6 cases. Great value at a discount. Graphically pretty good for an older game (with the exception of the mouths during talking scenes). Interesting…”

“A 12-year-old game can no longer keep up with evolving hardware; the amount of flashing textures is alarming. Despite all this, the story is what saves this game.”

4 of the 101 reviews raise this · 4 of them still recommend the game.

“As a fan of investigation games, it's quite an entertaining adventure, and a fairly easy 100%. I enjoyed the different small stories with the extra subplot about the Merry Men and of course the dispise between brothers.…”

“Absolutely loved it. Finished the game in almost 17 hours solving 6 cases. Great value at a discount. Graphically pretty good for an older game (with the exception of the mouths during talking scenes). Interesting…”