Home / Tags / Best Mystery Games

Best Mystery Games

Top 50 of 723 qualifying games — tagged Mystery (community voting), 1,000+ reviews · ranked by Wilson lower bound on Steam review score · review data as of 2026-10-22. Under each game: what its Steam reviewers most often mention (+ praise, − complaint), with how many of about 100 most-helpful reviews raise it — from the review consensus on each game's page.

1 The Thief, the Witch, the Toad, and the Mushroom. (2024) Choose Your Own Adventure · Interactive Fiction · Visual Novel · Free 99.7%1,137 reviews 2 Öoo (2025) Puzzle-Platformer · Metroidvania · 2D Platformer · $9.99 + Clever bomb-based puzzle design 79+ Wordless mechanic teaching 36− Brief overall runtime 5 99.4%7,036 reviews 3 The Mermaid Mask (2026) Detective · Adventure · Point & Click · $19.99 + Compelling mysteries and characters 72+ Charming animated presentation 55− Easy or poorly telegraphed puzzles 9 99.4%3,126 reviews 4 Project Kat - Paper Lily Prologue (2021) Psychological Horror · Pixel Graphics · Anime · Free + Engaging stories and memorable characters 9+ Strong pixel art and visual style 8 99.2%5,923 reviews 5 Paper Lily - Chapter 1 (2024) Pixel Graphics · Psychological Horror · Story Rich · Free + Intriguing emotional stories 47+ Creative puzzles and exploration 33 99.1%9,003 reviews 6 Please, Touch The Artwork 2 (2024) Casual · Adventure · Hidden Object · Free + beautiful hand-painted artworks 49+ hidden-object and repair puzzles 30− short one-hour experience 23 99.0%6,257 reviews 7 Sheepy: A Short Adventure (2024) Free to Play · Pixel Graphics · 2D Platformer · Free + atmospheric pixel art 58+ emotional synchronized soundtrack 52− short one-hour adventure 28 98.9%25,007 reviews 8 买个可乐饼吧！ - Buy a Croquette! (2024) RPGMaker · Mystery · Sci-fi · Free + Layered branching mystery story 24+ Exceptional quality for free 19− No English translation 8 98.8%8,634 reviews 9 The Upturned (2022) Comedy · Physics · Survival Horror · $9.99 + Fun physics-driven mechanics 47+ Funny, charming characters and dialogue 33− Short overall adventure 6 98.9%2,725 reviews 10 The Children of Clay (2025) Horror · Atmospheric · Detective · Free + Brief experiences fit well 30+ Atmospheric stop-motion visuals 29− Requests for longer versions 16 98.8%4,092 reviews 11 The Room 4: Old Sins (2021) Puzzle · Mystery · Point & Click · $8.99 + Well-designed puzzles with satisfying challenge 78+ Mysterious narrative with compelling revelations 23− Backtracking tedium disrupts gameplay flow 12 98.5%18,391 reviews 12 Servant of the Lake (2026) Puzzle · Adventure · Point & Click · $7.99 + clever, satisfying puzzles 62+ revealing, atmospheric lore 47− filler and random puzzles 11 98.5%7,889 reviews 13 The Supper (2020) Cooking · Point & Click · Adventure · Free + Stunning visual art and aesthetic 37+ Emotionally resonant story with impactful ending 33− Game is notably short 14 98.5%4,450 reviews 14 Chants of Sennaar (2023) Puzzle · Adventure · Singleplayer · $19.99 + satisfying language-deciphering puzzles 89+ striking stylized visuals 41− obtuse or overly easy puzzles 11 98.2%35,028 reviews 15 Look Outside (2025) RPG · Survival Horror · Horror · $9.99 + Deep turn-based survival systems 58+ Rich horror narrative 46 98.3%14,927 reviews 16 Frog Detective 3: Corruption at Cowboy County (2022) Comedy · Funny · Short · $4.99 + Emotional trilogy finale 35+ Simple cozy mystery gameplay 16− Repetitive fetch-quest gameplay 6 98.6%2,098 reviews 17 DELTARUNE (2025) Story Rich · Great Soundtrack · Pixel Graphics · $24.99 + Story-driven character writing 41+ Interactive, varied battle mechanics 32− Incomplete episodic content 8 98.1%137,700 reviews 18 Money for Girls: Amortized (2026) Visual Novel · Horror · LGBTQ+ · $15.00 98.7%1,301 reviews 19 Threefold Recital (2025) Drama · Mystery · Visual Novel · $14.99 98.3%5,800 reviews 20 Underground Blossom (2023) Escape Room · Adventure · Puzzle · $4.99 + Clever, intuitive puzzle design 34+ Rich interconnected character lore 27− External achievement unlock requirements 7 98.2%7,076 reviews 21 Z.A.T.O. // I Love the World and Everything In It (2025) Visual Novel · Philosophical · Mystery · Free + emotionally resonant narrative 74+ distinctive beautiful art style 31− confusing or unsatisfying ending 8 98.1%13,348 reviews 22 Monument Valley (2022) Puzzle · Relaxing · Adventure · $7.99 + Mind-bending perspective-based optical illusions 72+ Beautiful impossible geometry and minimalism 55− Relatively short but satisfying 12 98.1%8,902 reviews 23 Before Your Eyes (2021) Emotional · Narrative · Story Rich · $9.99 + Emotionally powerful, perspective-changing 94+ Innovative blink-tracking mechanic 24 97.9%23,995 reviews 24 BLACK BOX LSS - The Shining Immortal (2023) Visual Novel · RPG · Dating Sim · Free 98.4%1,949 reviews 25 The Wolf Among Us (2013) Adventure · Detective · Story Rich · $14.99 + gripping noir mystery and characters 53+ engaging choices and enjoyable QTEs 15− choices lacking meaningful consequences 10 97.9%40,391 reviews 26 Lost in Play (2022) Puzzle · Point & Click · Indie · $19.99 + satisfying and creative puzzles 79+ beautiful and charming animations 50− shorter than desired 16 98.0%9,382 reviews 27 Tactical Breach Wizards (2024) Turn-Based Tactics · Puzzle · Turn-Based Strategy · $19.99 + tight mechanics, flexible solutions 86+ witty dialogue, memorable characters 74− humor overreach in early dialogue 7 97.9%12,203 reviews 28 花火与幽灵少女 - Hanabi and Ghost girl (2025) Adventure · Puzzle · JRPG · Free 98.4%1,666 reviews 29 Cube Escape Collection (2020) Puzzle · Point & Click · Mystery · $4.99 + clever engaging rewarding puzzle design 44+ deep mysterious interconnected lore 31− tricky unintuitive frustrating puzzle logic 12 97.9%8,027 reviews 30 The Room (2014) Puzzle · Mystery · Point & Click · $4.99 + clever satisfying puzzle-box mechanics 69+ balanced thoughtful puzzle challenge 31− too short and quickly finished 12 97.7%31,914 reviews 31 Firework (2021) Horror · Indie · Puzzle · $9.99 + Emotionally resonant mystery tragedy 57+ Atmospheric hand-drawn visual presentation 34− Short three-to-four-hour experience 14 97.7%44,473 reviews 32 Scarlet Hollow (2021) Early Access · Choices Matter · Visual Novel · $24.99 + Branching horror mystery writing 74+ Meaningful choices and trait systems 47− Unfinished final chapters 6 97.9%5,334 reviews 33 Higurashi When They Cry Hou - Ch.6 Tsumihoroboshi (2018) Visual Novel · Horror · Adventure · $7.99 98.5%1,033 reviews 34 The Case of the Golden Idol (2022) Mystery · Detective · Investigation · $17.99 + Clever deductive reasoning puzzles 96+ Intriguing mystery with plot twists 47− Can bypass intended puzzle logic 15 97.8%11,012 reviews 35 Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney Trilogy (2019) Detective · Visual Novel · Story Rich · $29.99 + Fun deduction and courtroom mechanics 35+ Witty mysteries and lovable characters 30− Frustrating convoluted boring interactions 7 97.5%45,224 reviews 36 The Test: Final Revelation (2020) Simulation · Choose Your Own Adventure · Choices Matter · $1.99 + thought-provoking questions and tests 16+ heartwarming, positive messages 6− limited gameplay and leading questions 9 97.8%5,358 reviews 37 The Room Two (2016) Puzzle · Mystery · Point & Click · $4.99 + satisfying tactile puzzle solving 92+ fair moderate challenge level 23− hidden objects and obscure clues 8 97.5%21,823 reviews 38 Don't Escape: 4 Days to Survive (2019) Adventure · Pixel Graphics · Point & Click · $14.99 + Time management and logical puzzles 44+ Gripping, emotional post-apocalypse story 36 97.9%2,825 reviews 39 Gorogoa (2017) Puzzle · Hand-drawn · Indie · $14.99 + Clever perspective-based puzzle design 83+ Beautiful hand-drawn artwork 59− Very short playtime 27 97.5%20,820 reviews 40 The Test: Hypothesis Rising (2020) Simulation · Multiple Endings · Choices Matter · $1.99 + Accurate, reflective test conclusions 10+ Interesting varied question formats 7− Inaccurate or generic conclusions 9 97.6%5,918 reviews 41 Sally Face - Episode One (2016) Story Rich · Psychological Horror · Indie · $2.99 + compelling lore and characters 32+ engaging puzzles and secret-hunting 17 97.3%29,817 reviews 42 Stray (2022) Cats · Adventure · Atmospheric · $29.99 + satisfying cat exploration and puzzles 59+ detailed neon cyberpunk atmosphere 55− too-short adventure needing more 14 97.2%178,698 reviews 43 Higurashi When They Cry Hou - Ch.5 Meakashi (2017) Horror · Visual Novel · Adventure · $7.99 98.1%1,182 reviews 44 Your Turn To Die -Death Game By Majority- (2023) Early Access · Multiple Endings · Female Protagonist · $16.99 + Emotionally powerful character narrative 51+ Engaging trials, puzzles, and minigames 21 97.6%4,472 reviews 45 Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective (2023) Puzzle · Adventure · Mystery · $29.99 + Mystery-driven narrative with surprising emotional twists 61+ Fair challenging puzzles with satisfying solutions 44− Occasional frustrating sequences disrupt puzzle flow 7 97.4%8,679 reviews 46 Beacon Pines (2022) Visual Novel · Story Rich · Emotional · $19.99 + charming emotional mystery 74+ branching charm choices 36− minimal visual novel gameplay 11 97.6%4,518 reviews 47 ARMORED HEAD (2020) Arena Shooter · FPS · Action · $2.49 98.0%1,293 reviews 48 The Drifter (2025) Point & Click · Pixel Graphics · Story Rich · $19.99 + engaging, well-written narrative 59+ excellent voice acting 30− frustrating backtracking and logic 17 97.5%5,002 reviews 49 ギルド探求団へようこそ！ (2026) Detective · Adventure · Puzzle · $3.99 97.8%1,793 reviews 50 The Room VR: A Dark Matter (2020) Adventure · Puzzle · VR · $24.99 + creative VR puzzle design 59+ detailed immersive environments 23− short game duration 15 97.5%4,026 reviews