Home / Tags / Best Choices Matter Games

Best Choices Matter Games

Top 50 of 556 qualifying games — tagged Choices Matter (community voting), 1,000+ reviews · ranked by Wilson lower bound on Steam review score · review data as of 2026-05-20.

1 Monster Prom 4: Monster Con (2025) Visual Novel · Comedy · LGBTQ+ · 50K–100K owners · $14.99 99.3%1,444 reviews 2 Ib (2022) Story Rich · Pixel Graphics · Indie · 200K–500K owners · $9.09 99.0%4,386 reviews 3 Our Life: Beginnings & Always (2020) Visual Novel · Romance · LGBTQ+ · 500K–1M owners · Free 98.8%12,452 reviews 4 The Henry Stickmin Collection (2020) Funny · Multiple Endings · Choose Your Own Adventure · 1M–2M owners · $14.99 98.7%50,698 reviews 5 OneShot: World Machine Edition (2024) Puzzle · Exploration · Indie · 50K–100K owners · $9.99 98.8%2,807 reviews 6 CLANNAD (2015) Visual Novel · Anime · Story Rich · 200K–500K owners · $44.99 98.5%9,709 reviews 7 OneShot (2016) Story Rich · Pixel Graphics · Indie · 1M–2M owners · $9.99 98.3%53,704 reviews 8 I Wani Hug that Gator! (2024) Visual Novel · Story Rich · Romance · 200K–500K owners · $14.99 98.5%4,839 reviews 9 Endless Monday: Dreams and Deadlines (2023) Visual Novel · Choose Your Own Adventure · Interactive Fiction · 20K–50K owners · $9.99 98.8%1,510 reviews 10 A Date with Death (2023) Dating Sim · Visual Novel · LGBTQ+ · 500K–1M owners · Free 98.3%10,483 reviews 11 Balatro (2024) Card Game · Roguelike Deckbuilder · Rogue-like · 2M–5M owners · $14.99 98.0%153,566 reviews 12 The Case of the Golden Idol (2022) Mystery · Detective · Investigation · 500K–1M owners · $17.99 98.2%8,616 reviews 13 Scarlet Hollow (2021) Early Access · Choices Matter · Visual Novel · 50K–100K owners · $24.99 98.3%3,071 reviews 14 Aliya: Timelink (2024) RPG · Interactive Fiction · Visual Novel · 200K–500K owners · $2.99 98.2%6,512 reviews 15 Crab Champions (2023) Early Access · Action Roguelike · Soundtrack · 500K–1M owners · $7.49 97.9%26,860 reviews 16 The Wolf Among Us (2013) Adventure · Detective · Story Rich · 1M–2M owners · $14.99 97.9%35,678 reviews 17 Volcano Princess (2023) Life Sim · Multiple Endings · Choices Matter · 1M–2M owners · $10.99 97.8%41,180 reviews 18 Katawa Shoujo (2024) Visual Novel · Romance · Dating Sim · 100K–200K owners · Free 98.2%3,806 reviews 19 Hello Charlotte EP3: Childhood's End (2018) Story Rich · Psychological Horror · Gore · 50K–100K owners · $3.99 98.2%2,605 reviews 20 The Test: Final Revelation (2020) Simulation · Choose Your Own Adventure · Choices Matter · 0–20K owners · $1.99 98.0%5,360 reviews 21 Kindergarten 2 (2019) Adventure · Pixel Graphics · Gore · 200K–500K owners · $14.99 98.0%4,892 reviews 22 West of Loathing (2017) RPG · Comedy · Funny · 500K–1M owners · $10.99 97.7%9,758 reviews 23 Don't Escape: 4 Days to Survive (2019) Adventure · Pixel Graphics · Point & Click · 100K–200K owners · $14.99 98.0%2,272 reviews 24 The Test: Hypothesis Rising (2020) Simulation · Multiple Endings · Choices Matter · 20K–50K owners · $1.99 97.7%5,893 reviews 25 VA-11 Hall-A: Cyberpunk Bartender Action (2016) Cyberpunk · Visual Novel · Pixel Graphics · 500K–1M owners · $14.99 97.4%36,462 reviews 26 STEINS;GATE (2016) Visual Novel · Story Rich · Anime · 500K–1M owners · $29.99 97.4%21,078 reviews 27 In Stars And Time (2023) Story Rich · RPG · LGBTQ+ · 100K–200K owners · $19.99 97.6%6,184 reviews 28 The Walking Dead (2012) Zombies · Story Rich · Adventure · 2M–5M owners · $14.99 97.3%73,628 reviews 29 BAD END THEATER (2021) Multiple Endings · Visual Novel · Story Rich · 200K–500K owners · $9.99 97.5%8,332 reviews 30 Far Away (2021) Singleplayer · Visual Novel · Choices Matter · 200K–500K owners · $12.99 97.5%7,360 reviews 31 Outcore: Desktop Adventure (2022) Adventure · Psychological Horror · Free to Play · 500K–1M owners · Free 97.3%15,157 reviews 32 Monster Prom 3: Monster Roadtrip (2022) Visual Novel · LGBTQ+ · Dating Sim · 100K–200K owners · $11.99 97.6%3,112 reviews 33 Slay the Princess — The Pristine Cut (2023) Visual Novel · Choices Matter · Psychological Horror · 500K–1M owners · $17.99 97.1%23,963 reviews 34 Touhou Hero of Ice Fairy: Prologue (2021) Bullet Hell · Action · JRPG · 200K–500K owners · Free 97.4%3,307 reviews 35 Milk outside a bag of milk outside a bag of milk (2021) Psychological Horror · Visual Novel · Psychedelic · 500K–1M owners · $8.99 97.0%18,723 reviews 36 Undertale (2015) Great Soundtrack · Story Rich · Choices Matter · 5M–10M owners · $9.99 96.8%272,932 reviews 37 The Test (2020) Choose Your Own Adventure · Simulation · Multiple Endings · 500K–1M owners · $1.99 96.9%19,954 reviews 38 IRMÃO Grande & Brasileiro 2 (2021) Simulation · Casual · Party Game · 50K–100K owners · $19.99 97.7%1,197 reviews 39 BROK the InvestiGator (2022) Adventure · Point & Click · Beat 'em up · 50K–100K owners · $19.99 97.7%1,088 reviews 40 Coffee Talk Episode 2: Hibiscus & Butterfly (2023) Conversation · Relaxing · Pixel Graphics · 100K–200K owners · $14.99 97.3%2,312 reviews 41 Kingdom Rush Frontiers - Tower Defense (2016) Tower Defense · Strategy · 2D · 500K–1M owners · $9.99 96.8%9,408 reviews 42 The Walking Dead: The Telltale Definitive Series (2020) Choices Matter · Story Rich · Interactive Fiction · 500K–1M owners · $49.99 96.5%31,041 reviews 43 The Walking Dead: Season Two (2013) Zombies · Adventure · Story Rich · 1M–2M owners · $14.99 96.5%31,639 reviews 44 The Coffin of Andy and Leyley (2023) Psychological · Dark Comedy · Story Rich · 500K–1M owners · $11.99 96.5%30,157 reviews 45 Kindergarten (2017) Funny · Gore · Pixel Graphics · 200K–500K owners · $4.99 96.6%8,817 reviews 46 Tiny Bunny (2025) Visual Novel · Horror · Story Rich · 500K–1M owners · $7.69 96.5%19,608 reviews 47 I Was a Teenage Exocolonist (2022) Choices Matter · Life Sim · Deckbuilding · 200K–500K owners · $12.49 96.7%3,931 reviews 48 Life is Strange - Episode 1 (2015) Story Rich · Choices Matter · Great Soundtrack · 5M–10M owners · Free 96.2%169,201 reviews 49 Primordia (2012) Point & Click · Adventure · Post-apocalyptic · 100K–200K owners · $9.99 96.7%3,302 reviews 50 Homicipher (2024) Horror · Otome · Female Protagonist · 500K–1M owners · $13.99 96.4%6,540 reviews