Home / Tags / Best Sequel Games

Best Sequel Games

Top 44 of 44 qualifying games — tagged Sequel (community voting), 1,000+ reviews · ranked by Wilson lower bound on Steam review score · review data as of 2026-10-22. Under each game: what its Steam reviewers most often mention (+ praise, − complaint), with how many of about 100 most-helpful reviews raise it — from the review consensus on each game's page.

1 Frog Detective 3: Corruption at Cowboy County (2022) Comedy · Funny · Short · $4.99 + Emotional trilogy finale 35+ Simple cozy mystery gameplay 16− Repetitive fetch-quest gameplay 6 98.6%2,098 reviews 2 420BLAZEIT 2: GAME OF THE YEAR -=Dank Dreams and Goated Memes=- [#wow/11 Like and Subscribe] Poggerz Edition (2024) Satire · Action · FPS · $10.99 + creative level design and shooting 29+ self-aware nostalgic meme humor 12 98.4%1,687 reviews 3 Trails in the Sky 2nd Chapter (2026) RPG · JRPG · Story Rich · $59.99 + Emotional sequel story and characters 34+ Fluid, deep combat systems 19− Unfair regional pricing 9 97.0%3,522 reviews 4 Monster Prom 2: Monster Camp (2020) Dating Sim · LGBTQ+ · Comedy · $11.99 + Humorous and absurd core experience 28+ Diverse, attractive character designs 15− Punishing difficulty and unclear mechanics 5 96.3%6,143 reviews 5 Psychonauts 2 (2021) 3D Platformer · Story Rich · Singleplayer · $59.99 + Creative level design and polished mechanics 35+ Creative writing and character depth 32− Simplified gameplay and repetitive formula 7 95.6%14,519 reviews 6 Zup! 7 (2017) Puzzle · Casual · Indie · $1.99 95.5%2,379 reviews 7 Poly Bridge 2 (2020) Building · Simulation · Puzzle · $14.99 + Fun, engaging puzzle mechanics 65+ Challenging yet rewarding difficulty curve 10− Unfairly difficult, punishing missteps 11 95.0%8,235 reviews 8 Frog Detective 2: The Case of the Invisible Wizard (2019) Comedy · Casual · Short · $4.99 + Whimsical humorous character writing 29+ Simple, silly detective interactions 20− Very short one-hour experiences 19 95.0%2,201 reviews 9 Thief II: The Metal Age (2012) Stealth · Classic · Steampunk · $6.99 + Rich stealth systems and level design 31+ Garrett and Karras's compelling world 7− Weak late-game missions 11 94.2%2,155 reviews 10 Jurassic World Evolution 3 (2025) Simulation · Dinosaurs · Strategy · $40.19 + Creative park building 60+ Detailed dinosaurs and graphics 19− Limited or repetitive mechanics 22 93.3%14,091 reviews 11 Bendy and the Dark Revival (2022) Horror · Action · Singleplayer · $19.99 + improved mechanics and combat feel 31+ emotionally resonant storytelling 23− broken stealth and redundant combat 16 91.9%16,367 reviews 12 CONTROL Resonant (2026) Hack and Slash · Action RPG · Story Rich · $59.99 + Fast, satisfying melee combat 54+ Smooth, well-optimized performance 39− Repetitive button-mashing combat 11 91.6%19,200 reviews 13 The Last of Us Part II Remastered (2025) Story Rich · Post-apocalyptic · Third-Person Shooter · $49.99 + bold, emotionally powerful narrative 63+ smooth, improved combat mechanics 52− disjointed, unsatisfying narrative 18 90.9%56,132 reviews 14 Jurassic World Evolution 2 (2021) Dinosaurs · Building · Simulation · $59.99 + fun dinosaur park management 77+ beautiful detailed dinosaur visuals 10− stuck dinosaurs and broken features 7 90.4%47,175 reviews 15 The Legend of Heroes: Kuro no Kiseki (2022) RPG · JRPG · Interactive Fiction · $49.99 91.2%1,733 reviews 16 The Book of Unwritten Tales 2 (2015) Fantasy · Adventure · Point & Click · $29.99 + Humorous, lovable characters 39+ Clever, varied puzzles 20− Unresolved cliffhanger endings 18 91.3%1,015 reviews 17 Hollow Knight: Silksong (2025) Metroidvania · Difficult · Indie · $19.99 + refined combat and movement 51+ beautiful hand-drawn worlds 35− punishing difficulty 27 89.5%426,154 reviews 18 Lorelai (2019) Adventure · Horror · Female Protagonist · $2.69 90.7%1,672 reviews 19 Crash Drive 2 (2015) Racing · Multiplayer · Action · $4.99 89.9%1,489 reviews 20 Glass Masquerade 3: Honeylines (2023) Puzzle · 2D · Relaxing · $4.99 + varied puzzle modes and shapes 37+ beautiful colorful puzzle artwork 34− lost stained-glass aesthetic 21 89.4%1,221 reviews 21 Monster Boy and the Cursed Kingdom (2019) Adventure · Action · Indie · $29.99 + Transforming forms and puzzles 48+ Colorful hand-drawn visuals 34− Sudden and punishing difficulty spikes 21 88.3%2,658 reviews 22 Beyond a Steel Sky (2020) Adventure · Point & Click · Cyberpunk · $34.99 + Logical puzzles and helpful hints 36+ Engaging, thoughtful science-fiction narrative 30− Repetitive or unintuitive puzzle mechanics 8 87.9%1,669 reviews 23 Oik 3 (2017) Puzzle · Minimalist · Physics · $0.99 86.9%1,064 reviews 24 Castlevania: Lords of Shadow 2 (2014) Action · Adventure · Vampire · $39.99 + dynamic, fluid combat system 20+ beautiful graphics and aesthetics 10− poorly designed stealth sections 14 84.7%6,548 reviews 25 Barro 2020 (2019) Indie · Racing · Sports · $0.49 + Simple arcade racing 13+ Cheap sale pricing 7− Repetitive, low-effort racing 7 85.0%2,141 reviews 26 Command: Modern Operations (2019) Simulation · Military · Strategy · $79.99 + Deep military simulation 35+ Extensive scenario-building options 7− Steep learning curve 27 85.0%1,645 reviews 27 Sunless Skies: Sovereign Edition (2019) Steampunk · Lovecraftian · Exploration · $24.99 84.3%3,482 reviews 28 Barro F (2020) Indie · Racing · Sports · $4.99 + simple satisfying arcade racing 13+ cheap entertainment for the price 9− repetitive shallow racing mechanics 7 84.3%2,560 reviews 29 Barro Racing (2020) Indie · Racing · Sports · $4.99 84.1%1,356 reviews 30 WRC 7 FIA World Rally Championship (2017) Racing · Automobile Sim · Multiplayer · $1.99 + enjoyable and engaging rally gameplay 50+ great value at sale prices 10− broken physics and poor handling 7 82.4%15,807 reviews 31 THE LEGEND OF HEROES: HAJIMARI NO KISEKI (2021) RPG · JRPG · Anime · $59.99 + English patches enable timely play 9+ Interconnected character and story arcs 7− Severe drops and slow loading 8 83.8%1,112 reviews 32 THE GAME OF LIFE 2 (2020) Board Game · Multiplayer · Party · $12.49 + fun addictive digital board game 51+ fun with friends and family 27− boring repetitive luck-based shallow 22 77.9%4,645 reviews 33 The Legend of Heroes: Kai no Kiseki -Farewell, O Zemuria- (2025) RPG · JRPG · Interactive Fiction · $57.99 78.4%1,069 reviews 34 Fishing: North Atlantic - Enhanced Edition (2020) Simulation · Fishing · Naval · $34.99 76.7%2,777 reviews 35 Frostpunk 2 (2024) Strategy · City Builder · Survival · $44.99 + deep political and resource-management systems 49+ compelling continuation with moral dilemmas 16− detached, tedious macro-scale micromanagement 24 74.8%27,212 reviews 36 Democracy 3 (2013) Political Sim · Simulation · Politics · $24.99 + interconnected policy consequences 16− limited, unrealistic policy strategies 27 74.1%7,256 reviews 37 The Legend of Heroes: Kuro no Kiseki Ⅱ -CRIMSON SiN- (2023) RPG · JRPG · Interactive Fiction · $23.99 + Character development and strong cast 25+ Expanded combat and customization 13− Limited main-story progression 29 75.6%1,017 reviews 38 Barro GT (2022) Indie · Racing · Sports · $4.99 + Simple, fun arcade racing 20+ Cheap price, worthwhile content 10− Shallow, repetitive racing 14 70.8%2,569 reviews 39 Evil Genius 2: World Domination (2021) Strategy · Base-Building · Villain Protagonist · $39.99 + fun addictive core loop 47+ charming 1960s aesthetic polish 13− repetitive grinding endless waiting 60 69.1%13,253 reviews 40 The Incredible Adventures of Van Helsing III (2015) RPG · Action · Adventure · $14.99 + hack-and-slash combat 27+ quirky trilogy conclusion 19− shallow or clunky combat 23 64.8%1,385 reviews 41 Biped 2 (2025) Collectathon · Co-op · 3D Platformer · $14.99 + four-player friend co-op 19+ creative puzzle mechanics 15− unpolished new mechanics 8 64.5%1,131 reviews 42 Monstrum 2 (2022) Horror · Online Co-Op · Survival Horror · Free + Fun with friends 12+ Enjoyable monster gameplay 10− Dead or closing servers 22 51.3%1,011 reviews 43 Sheltered 2 (2021) Survival · Resource Management · Post-apocalyptic · $19.99 + shelter management and exploration 18− game-breaking bugs 31 45.4%2,221 reviews 44 Rocksmith+ (2024) Music · Education · Simulation · Free + Effective instrument-learning practice 10− Expensive subscription locks songs 26 18.1%2,146 reviews