Home / Tags / Best Baseball Games

Best Baseball Games

Top 17 of 17 qualifying games — tagged Baseball (community voting), 1,000+ reviews · ranked by Wilson lower bound on Steam review score · review data as of 2026-10-22. Under each game: what its Steam reviewers most often mention (+ praise, − complaint), with how many of about 100 most-helpful reviews raise it — from the review consensus on each game's page.

1 Jerma's Big Adventure (2021) Comedy · 2D Platformer · Dinosaurs · Free 97.6%1,389 reviews 2 Backyard Baseball '97 (2024) Sports · Casual · Baseball · $9.99 + Fun, strategic baseball gameplay 61− Frustratingly hard learning curve 6 97.2%2,295 reviews 3 FlatOut 2 (2006) Racing · Combat Racing · Multiplayer · $9.99 + Destruction physics, responsive handling, memorable AI 61+ Iconic 2000s rock soundtrack 20− Rubber-banding AI and endgame difficulty 10 95.9%22,353 reviews 4 OFF (2025) RPG · Pixel Graphics · Story Rich · $14.99 + Surreal unsettling stories 24+ Strong new soundtrack and music 21− Tedious repetitive combat encounters 11 95.8%3,515 reviews 5 Titanium Court (2026) Surreal · Funny · Match 3 · $14.99 + Sharp, surreal writing 51+ Genre-blending strategic loops 39− Twee or unsatisfying writing 5 94.4%1,242 reviews 6 Out of the Park Baseball 21 (2020) Sports · Simulation · Strategy · Free 91.8%1,677 reviews 7 Out of the Park Baseball 20 (2019) Sports · Simulation · Strategy · Free + deep baseball management simulation 85+ steady updates and developer commitment 9− AI, injuries, and limited improvements 11 92.0%1,089 reviews 8 Super Mega Baseball 3 (2020) Baseball · Sports · Arcade · $44.99 + Refined arcade baseball mechanics 32+ Scalable, challenging difficulty 7− Abrupt difficulty spikes and CPU cheating 5 91.3%2,098 reviews 9 Super Mega Baseball 2 (2018) Sports · Baseball · Simulation · Free 88.9%1,041 reviews 10 Out of the Park Baseball 25 (2024) Simulation · Sports · Strategy · Free + Deep, realistic baseball management 31+ Highly time-consuming baseball seasons 7− Questionable AI and balance 11 87.6%1,018 reviews 11 Out of the Park Baseball 22 (2021) Sports · Baseball · Sandbox · Free 86.0%1,674 reviews 12 Out of the Park Baseball 23 (2022) Simulation · Sports · Strategy · Free + Deep baseball management simulation 36+ Highly addictive franchise play 5− Ruined or missing save data 11 83.7%1,006 reviews 13 Cricket 22 (2021) Simulation · Sports · 3D · $44.99 + Immersive, responsive cricket gameplay 15+ Realistic graphics and detailed grounds 9− Fielding glitches, freezes, and crashes 16 81.3%1,756 reviews 14 Backyard Baseball (2026) Sports · Baseball · PvP · $35.99 + Fun mechanics and powerups 11+ High-quality graphics and faithful visuals 5− Batting and fielding feel awful 13 81.3%1,338 reviews 15 MLB 9 Innings Rivals 26 (2025) Sports · Free to Play · Baseball · Free + varied baseball gameplay 20+ good free baseball value 10− random hit outcomes 8 79.4%1,792 reviews 16 Super Mega Baseball 4 (2023) Sports · Simulation · Multiplayer · $49.99 + customizable arcade-sim baseball 44+ worth it on sale 9− scripted AI and shallow systems 15 79.5%1,504 reviews 17 eBaseball™: PRO SPIRIT (2026) Action · Sports · Baseball · Free + Deep baseball modes and mechanics 25+ Realistic graphics and character models 11− Weak baseball mechanics 9 78.1%1,838 reviews