Mafia II: Definitive Edition

29 of the 105 reviews raise this · 15 of them still recommend the game.

“Buggy mess, somehow a significantly lower quality than Mafia: Definitive Edition. Gameplay and story is a significantly different pace compared to the first game. If you enjoyed the first game, there's no guarantee that…”

“Definitely a great one in the mafia series has some bugs same as its original counterpart but not game ending. More collectibles since original but thats only wanted posters dlc was good but the driving took forever if…”

“Nostalgic game for me, loved all the Mafia Games. few minor bugs here and there but still a banger for sure”

18 of the 105 reviews raise this · 6 of them still recommend the game.

“Buggy mess, somehow a significantly lower quality than Mafia: Definitive Edition. Gameplay and story is a significantly different pace compared to the first game. If you enjoyed the first game, there's no guarantee that…”

“Definitely a great one in the mafia series has some bugs same as its original counterpart but not game ending. More collectibles since original but thats only wanted posters dlc was good but the driving took forever if…”

“Mafia II: Definitive Edition After playing Mafia: Definitive Edition, this was not what I expected. The game feels more like a simple remaster rather than a full remake. The graphics are only slightly improved, and some…”

16 of the 105 reviews raise this · 10 of them still recommend the game.

“Mafia II: Definitive Edition After playing Mafia: Definitive Edition, this was not what I expected. The game feels more like a simple remaster rather than a full remake. The graphics are only slightly improved, and some…”

“Mafia 1 remaster is okay, but this one is a half-baked remaster. Some character models are just awful and I experienced some glitches, frame rate drops, and crashes, even on my higher end PC.”

“This game suffers the same thing Yakuza 3 Remastered did. If you bought this you most likely own the trilogy and thus played Mafia 1 Definitive first, so its fair to expect the same kind of remake from this. This is NOT…”

12 of the 105 reviews raise this · 4 of them still recommend the game.

“Buggy mess, somehow a significantly lower quality than Mafia: Definitive Edition. Gameplay and story is a significantly different pace compared to the first game. If you enjoyed the first game, there's no guarantee that…”

“The story is decent overall, but it feels very unstable and repetitive. The game constantly goes in cycles: you earn money, lose everything, rebuild, and then lose it all again. Vito’s life keeps switching between…”

“Everyone seems to love Vito. Even on Reddit...but personally, he ranks as my third favorite Mafia protagonist. He feels pretty linear, with little character development. It makes sense given his goal of escaping the…”

11 of the 105 reviews raise this · 5 of them still recommend the game.

“Mafia is always a must-play for those who enjoy story oriented games. Except mafia 3, we don't talk about that one. Fair warning on the DLCs though, they are crap. Getting the best score on them which is tied to…”

“Game saves are gone every time I open the game. OS - Win 11 pro,”

“A bit grindy as compared to the first game in terms of achievements but the story, gameplay, the world and characters all are just too well done. I played the original version back in ps3 and this remake stays true to…”