Home / Tags / Best Supernatural Games

Best Supernatural Games

Top 50 of 185 qualifying games — tagged Supernatural (community voting), 1,000+ reviews · ranked by Wilson lower bound on Steam review score · review data as of 2026-10-22. Under each game: what its Steam reviewers most often mention (+ praise, − complaint), with how many of about 100 most-helpful reviews raise it — from the review consensus on each game's page.

1 The Mermaid Mask (2026) Detective · Adventure · Point & Click · $19.99 + Compelling mysteries and characters 72+ Charming animated presentation 55− Easy or poorly telegraphed puzzles 9 99.4%3,126 reviews 2 Project Kat - Paper Lily Prologue (2021) Psychological Horror · Pixel Graphics · Anime · Free + Engaging stories and memorable characters 9+ Strong pixel art and visual style 8 99.2%5,923 reviews 3 Paper Lily - Chapter 1 (2024) Pixel Graphics · Psychological Horror · Story Rich · Free + Intriguing emotional stories 47+ Creative puzzles and exploration 33 99.1%9,003 reviews 4 The Children of Clay (2025) Horror · Atmospheric · Detective · Free + Brief experiences fit well 30+ Atmospheric stop-motion visuals 29− Requests for longer versions 16 98.8%4,092 reviews 5 A Date with Death (2023) Dating Sim · Visual Novel · LGBTQ+ · Free + well-written character and engaging storytelling 58+ choice-rich dialogue with witty banter 38− dialogue occasionally awkward or cringey 6 98.0%14,959 reviews 6 Crow Country (2024) Survival Horror · Exploration · Female Protagonist · $19.99 + Solid mechanics and satisfying exploration 83+ Engaging narrative with surprising emotional twists 53− Combat feels clunky and imbalanced 13 98.0%8,366 reviews 7 Firework (2021) Horror · Indie · Puzzle · $9.99 + Emotionally resonant mystery tragedy 57+ Atmospheric hand-drawn visual presentation 34− Short three-to-four-hour experience 14 97.7%44,473 reviews 8 Scarlet Hollow (2021) Early Access · Choices Matter · Visual Novel · $24.99 + Branching horror mystery writing 74+ Meaningful choices and trait systems 47− Unfinished final chapters 6 97.9%5,334 reviews 9 Grimhook (2023) Action · Adventure · First-Person · Free + fluid movement parkour combat 63+ beautiful visuals and artstyle 20− too short needs more content 58 97.9%4,225 reviews 10 Psychopomp (2024) Psychological Horror · Horror · Free to Play · Free + Disturbing surreal visuals 22+ Hammer-based combat and exploration 20− Very short game duration 8 97.6%7,746 reviews 11 Sally Face - Episode One (2016) Story Rich · Psychological Horror · Indie · $2.99 + compelling lore and characters 32+ engaging puzzles and secret-hunting 17 97.3%29,817 reviews 12 Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective (2023) Puzzle · Adventure · Mystery · $29.99 + Mystery-driven narrative with surprising emotional twists 61+ Fair challenging puzzles with satisfying solutions 44− Occasional frustrating sequences disrupt puzzle flow 7 97.4%8,679 reviews 13 The Drifter (2025) Point & Click · Pixel Graphics · Story Rich · $19.99 + engaging, well-written narrative 59+ excellent voice acting 30− frustrating backtracking and logic 17 97.5%5,002 reviews 14 A Space For The Unbound - Prologue (2020) Pixel Graphics · 1990's · Adventure · Free 97.9%1,320 reviews 15 Sorry We're Closed (2024) LGBTQ+ · Female Protagonist · Survival Horror · $24.99 + Innovative third-eye combat 53+ Gorgeous neon collage visuals 51− Awkward aiming and camera shifts 9 97.7%2,039 reviews 16 I MAED A GAM3 W1TH Z0MB1ES 1N IT!!!1 (2021) Zombies · Twin Stick Shooter · Top-Down Shooter · Free + Memorable soundtrack and music 9+ Exceptional value for minimal price 7 97.7%1,845 reviews 17 HER TREES : PUZZLE DREAM (2026) Puzzle · Point & Click · Relaxing · $3.99 + creative visual puzzles 76+ challenging but fair puzzles 35− short under-two-hour experience 23 97.6%2,064 reviews 18 A Space for the Unbound (2023) Story Rich · Pixel Graphics · Emotional · $9.99 + moving story about loss and acceptance 73+ gorgeous pixel art and nostalgic aesthetic 34− slow pacing and tedious quest design 16 97.1%7,883 reviews 19 Blackwell Epiphany (2014) Adventure · Point & Click · Indie · $9.99 + emotionally resonant series finale 66+ satisfying, reasonable puzzles 19− rushed, inconclusive plot threads 15 97.7%1,014 reviews 20 Enigma of Fear (2024) Mystery · Investigation · Supernatural · $29.99 + Creative puzzle design 43+ Intriguing paranormal mystery 27− Combat mechanics frustrate 12 96.5%10,352 reviews 21 If On A Winter's Night, Four Travelers (2021) Point & Click · Story Rich · Pixel Graphics · Free + tragic, well-written stories 15+ beautiful pixel art 14 96.2%2,839 reviews 22 The Rewinder (2021) Adventure · Mystery · Pixel Graphics · $14.99 95.8%7,372 reviews 23 Detective Grimoire (2014) Exploration · Point & Click · Visual Novel · $6.99 + charming character-focused mysteries 45+ simple point-and-click investigations 42− short two-to-four-hour campaigns 31 96.0%2,668 reviews 24 [Nightmare Files] Clap Clap (2024) Horror · Free to Play · Psychological Horror · Free + Clap mechanic and effective scares 38+ Free game offers worthwhile entertainment 15− Short, limited horror experience 21 95.7%5,387 reviews 25 Wylde Flowers (2022) Cozy · Simulation · Farming Sim · $24.99 + engaging emotional storylines 25+ varied farming and crafting systems 20− grindy or dragged late game 5 95.9%2,772 reviews 26 PARANORMASIGHT: The Seven Mysteries of Honjo (2023) Visual Novel · Adventure · Anime · $19.99 + Compelling mystery and strong storytelling 85+ Beautiful visuals and character design 27− Rushed or disappointing endings 18 95.5%7,312 reviews 27 ASTLIBRA Revision (2022) Action RPG · 2D · Side Scroller · $24.99 + satisfying deep evolving combat 62+ twisty emotional time-travel narrative 49− grindy gear and reward pacing 12 95.0%31,944 reviews 28 Unavowed (2018) Adventure · Point & Click · Indie · $14.99 + Compelling supernatural narratives 48+ Strong voice acting and music 20− Light, underwhelming puzzles 8 95.6%2,637 reviews 29 Creaks (2020) Puzzle · Hand-drawn · Atmospheric · $19.99 + Clever, fair puzzle design 80+ Hand-drawn beautiful visual design 54− Timing-focused repetitive puzzle design 7 95.0%6,192 reviews 30 The Séance of Blake Manor (2025) Supernatural · Detective · Puzzle · $19.99 + Clue-driven deduction 62+ Irish folklore and history 60− Repetitive investigation loop 15 95.2%4,165 reviews 31 Phasmophobia (2020) Horror · Online Co-Op · Multiplayer · $13.99 + fun ghost-hunting mechanics 64+ more fun with friends 30− frequent post-update bugs 10 94.4%840,112 reviews 32 Persona 3 Reload (2024) JRPG · RPG · Anime · $59.99 + emotionally powerful mortality narrative 52+ engaging turn-based combat systems 31− repetitive Tartarus dungeon grind 28 94.3%64,450 reviews 33 Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines (2007) RPG · Vampire · Cult Classic · $9.99 + Immersive roleplay, unique vampire clans 72+ Witty dialogue, compelling characters and lore 41− Crashes without unofficial patch fix 39 94.4%15,472 reviews 34 DEAD LETTER DEPT. (2025) Horror · Typing · Mystery · $14.99 + Atmospheric typing horror 79+ Multiple endings and choices 19− Repetitive typing and unclear progression 6 95.1%1,864 reviews 35 PARANORMASIGHT: The Mermaid's Curse (2026) Adventure · RPG · Simulation · $17.49 + Strong characters and fast twists 36+ Creative puzzles and interconnected mechanics 16− Slow lore dumps and weak endings 12 94.9%2,761 reviews 36 GYLT (2023) Adventure · Action · Horror · $19.99 95.1%1,296 reviews 37 Content Warning (2024) Online Co-Op · Horror · Multiplayer · $7.99 + funny recording-driven horror gameplay 91+ hilarious co-op with friends 53− frequent glitches and crashes 9 93.8%163,640 reviews 38 Five Nights at Freddy's (2014) Horror · Singleplayer · Survival Horror · $4.99 + tense power-management horror loop 36+ tense, escalating night challenges 13− boring, repetitive, weak horror gameplay 7 93.8%59,667 reviews 39 The Darkside Detective (2017) Point & Click · Detective · Pixel Graphics · $14.99 + Sharp humor and lovable characters 60+ Satisfying clicking and exploration 21− Moon logic, illogical solutions 8 94.2%5,263 reviews 40 Dollmare (2024) Simulation · Horror · 3D · $4.99 + Engaging doll sorting mechanics 57+ Creepy atmosphere without cheap jumpscares 43− Short or overstretched campaigns 13 94.5%2,184 reviews 41 Jaded (2025) Precision Platformer · 2D Platformer · Platformer · $4.99 + Fluid combat and platforming 33+ Strong, charming narrative 23− Bugged cannons and missing features 6 94.4%2,111 reviews 42 Friendly Fire (2020) Free to Play · Indie · Casual · Free 94.8%1,041 reviews 43 Mutazione (2019) Relaxing · Story Rich · Atmospheric · $19.99 + heartfelt character-driven writing 58+ lush hand-drawn visuals 33− minimal, tedious gameplay 12 94.6%1,414 reviews 44 At Dead Of Night (2020) Survival Horror · Horror · Strategy · $15.99 + Distinctive point-and-click mechanics 32+ Live-action realistic visuals 16− Progress-blocking and visual glitches 6 93.8%3,589 reviews 45 Amanda the Adventurer (2023) Horror · First-Person · Puzzle · $8.99 + clever engaging puzzle design 70+ creepy atmospheric horror vibes 31− game is too short 7 93.5%7,297 reviews 46 The Bridge Curse 2: The Extrication (2024) Mystery · Story Rich · Psychological Horror · $24.99 + interwoven supernatural story 33+ engaging puzzles and exploration 27− confusing or weak narrative 12 93.8%3,328 reviews 47 Amnesia: The Bunker (2023) Horror · Survival Horror · Atmospheric · $24.99 + stalker AI and emergent gameplay mechanics 59+ atmospheric horror with genuine terror 41− becomes tedious and scripted later 8 93.3%12,669 reviews 48 The Scourge | Tai Ương (2026) Early Access · Horror · Singleplayer · $19.99 + deep Vietnamese family narrative 45+ Vietnamese cultural atmosphere and visuals 33− uneven horror and stealth mechanics 10 94.1%1,332 reviews 49 Schrödinger's Call (2026) Visual Novel · Female Protagonist · Post-apocalyptic · $17.99 + emotionally devastating human stories 78+ gorgeous mixed-media visuals 54− repetitive, formulaic storytelling 15 94.0%1,391 reviews 50 Invokyr (2026) Early Access · Horror · Online Co-Op · $9.74 93.8%1,232 reviews