Hey everyone!
Sorry for the delay, but I've got another balance update for you all. It takes a while to accumulate a statistically relevant amount of data, so I had to wait a little longer than I would've liked. But here we are! This update is addressing some of the knock-on effects of the last update to bring everything a little more into balance. Hopefully this is the last huge sweeping character spell update, and future balance patches will focus on Worthiness balance changes more heavily. As always, before the balance stuff, there are a few bug and general fixes:
Bug/General Fixes
Korean text for Poisoned Foliage fixed to indicate the correct DV limit for additional status infliction
Fixed the Korean translation for Burn Bright that did not accurately reflect the effect of the spell
Fixed a bug with Poisoned Foliage that did not inflict any status at exactly 7 DV
The completion percentage in the profile correct screen will now correctly account for discovered dice bodies
Fixed an issue in the reset profile mode of the profile panel where it wouldn't display the profile name
Mana Nexus will now properly reroll both dice
Tiny Ogre's damage + might gain attack will now show the buff intention
Origin of Sickness' damage + might gain + curse dice attack (Worthiness only) now appropriately shows the buff intention instead of the debuff intention.
Balance Changes
Enemies
\[Dev's Note: Interestingly, the data showed that the overall win rate was higher in Worthiness 10 than on base difficulty. I imagine that this is because only the most skilled players are playing on the highest difficulty, but this also means that they aren't always getting the challenge they desire out of the highest difficulty mode. This balance update mostly focuses on changes to combat-related Worthiness, but the next balance update will focus on Worthiness in a more holistic way.]
Tiny Ogre: Damage value for damage + buff attack decreased by 1 in all difficulties
Tiny Ogre: HP decreased by 1 in Worthiness
Hammer: Damage value for flat damage attack changed from 11-12 damage to 10-12 damage in Worthiness.
Hexbeast: HP decreased by 1-2 in base difficulty
Spellmaw: Unit ability dice cost changed from Countdown 17 to Countdown 14 in all difficulties
The Replicator: HP decreased by 1 in all difficulties
Bladed Dancer: HP increased by 4 in all difficulties
Ruby Demon: Damage value for all attacks increased by 2 in all difficulties
Arena Hero: Starting Hexproof reduced by 1 in all difficulties
Master of the Armory: Damage value for first damage-dealing attack increased by 5 in Worthiness
Master of the Armory: Repeat value for first multi-attack increased by 1 in Worthiness
Demon of Misfortune: HP reduced by 7 in base difficulty
Demon of Misfortune: Starting Hexproof decreased by 1 in base difficulty
Demon of Misfortune: Damage value for all phase 1 attacks increased by 3 in Worthiness
Demon of Misfortune: Damage value for all phase 2 attacks increased by 7 in Worthiness
The Sacrifice: HP increased by 10 in Worthiness
The Sacrifice: Retaliate gain in bound + buff attack (Worthiness only) increased by 1 in Worthiness
Doom Wizard: Damage value for all attacks increased by 6 in all difficulties
Parasitic Wurm: Damage value for damage + debuff attack and damage + barrier attack increased by 2 in base difficulty
Parasitic Wurm: HP increased by 6 in base difficulty
Orb: Barrier gain for all attacks increased by 2 in base difficulty and by more than that in varying amounts in Worthiness
Chaos Mass: HP increased by 15 in Worthiness
Chaos Mass: Damage value for all attacks increased by 5 in Worthiness
Chaos Mass: Flame Resist gain in damage + gain Flame Resist attack (vs Pyromancer only) increased by 5 in all difficulties
Chaos Mass: Energy Pulse gain in damage + gain Energy Pulse attack (vs Thaumancer only) increased by 3 in all difficulties
Deathless One: Damage value for damage + buff attack increased by 2 in all difficulties
Deathless One: HP decreased by 20 in Worthiness
Exploding Ether: Damage value for self-destruct attack increased by 5 in all difficulties
Exploding Ether: HP increased by 5 in Worthiness
Origin of Sickness: Starting Hexproof increased by 1 on base difficulty
Ghost of Beauty: Damage value for damage + barrier attack increased by 8 in all difficulties
Ghost of Beauty: Repeat value for multi-attack increased by 2 in Worthiness
Ghost of Beauty: Damage value for Multi-attack increased by 1 in all difficulties
Ghost of Beauty: Barrier gain for might + barrier attack increased by 10 in all difficulties
Avatar of the Soul: Starting Hexproof decreased by 1 in all difficulties
Avatar of the Soul: HP increased by 70 in Worthiness
Avatar of the Soul: Damage value for damage + curse dice attack increased by 5 in Worthiness
Avatar of the Soul: Repeat value for multi-attack increased by 1 in Worthiness
Avatar of the Soul: Damage value for damage + barrier attack increased by 5 in Worthiness
Avatar of the Soul: Might gain for debuff + buff attack increased by 2 in Worthiness
Avatar of the Soul: Hexproof gain for debuff + buff attack increased by 1 in Worthiness
Dice Bodies/ Runes
\[Dev's Note: The numbers look pretty good for these actually. I personally think that Spiked and Toughness rune are a bit too strong, but the data doesn't really bear that out yet. I've got my eyes open though.]
No changes
Spells
Gaiamancer
\[Dev's Note: Gaiamancer's win rate stayed mostly the same as last time (around 15% on base difficulty) despite the buffs, since many of the enemies also got buffs. The changes to enemies in this update are a bit more minute (at least on base difficulty), so hopefully this is the last major sweeping update to the character. Mostly buffs here.]
Gaia's Protection (unit ability) - Grounded gain in both DV conditions increased by 1
Abrasive - Dice Cost: Min 7 > Min 6
Boulder Toss - Damage: 24 > 26
Carved in Stone - Damage: 8 > 7
Connect with Gaia - Damage: 14 > 15
Deep Roots - Dice cost: Countdown 18 > Countdown 21
Duneburst - Sandstorm Intensity gain: 4 > 5
Fertilize - Charge count: 2 > 1
Gift of Gaia - Dice cost: Countdown 25 > Countdown 30
Grounded Fist - Damage: DV + 5 > DV + 6
Huddle Up - Sandstorm Intensity gain: 1 > 2
Mined Explosives - Damage on spell consumed: 25 > 28
Mined Steel - Barrier gain on spell consumed: 20 > 24
Nature's Armor - Rarity change: Common > Uncommon
Plate Slip - Damage: 15 > 16
Poisoned Foliage - Dice cost: Countdown 5 > Countdown 6
Rising Stampede - Damage: 4 > 5
Rush of Thorns - Rarity change: Common > Uncommon
Seek Shelter - Rarity change: Uncommon > Common
Staying Power - Dice cost: Any Rune + Max 2 > Any Rune + Max 3
Sweeping Kick - Damage: 8 > 9
Topple the Spire - Damage: 11 > 13
Turn to Sand - Rarity change: Uncommon > Common
Wrap in Sand - Dice cost: Max 2 + Max 2 > Max 3 + Max 3
Pyromancer
\[Dev's Note: Pyromancer's win rate dropped off a lot more than I expected (from around 21% to around 17%) with the last update. It seems that Pyromancer is particularly sensitive to changes in HP and is the character most affected by enemy Hexproof. This makes sense in retrospect. The changes this update are meant to bring Pyromancer back to it's previous winrate, as Pyromancer was the benchmark character last time. The biggest changes here are improvements to inflicting burn, both on yourself and enemies. Since Burn shifts from being damage output to scaling in the late-game, there were some issues with being able to inflict Burn quickly enough to make a difference in later combats. Hopefully this update addresses that issue.]
All Are Kindling - Repeat: 2 > 3
Blackflame Sproutling - Repeat: 2 > 3
Blueflame Spark - Rarity change: Uncommon > Common
Blueflame's Source - Dice cost: Countdown 25 > Countdown 21
Blueflame Tackle - Damage: 9 > 10
Blueflame Tackle - Charge count: 3 > 4
Bolstered by Suffering - Barrier: 7 > 8
Burgeoning Blackflame - Dice cost: Min 6 > Min 5
Burn and Run - Barrier: 5 > 6
Burn Bright - Damage multiplier: 4x > 5x
Embrace Heat - Flame Resist gain: 2 > 4
Enfeebling Sear - Burn inflicted: 2 > 3
Engulf - Dice cost: Countdown 13 > Countdown 11
Flame Stack - Dice cost: Max 4 > Any
Flame Stack - Consume count: 2 > 1
Flame Stack - Rarity change: Uncommon > Common
Flame Whip - Damage: 3 > 5
Focus Spark - Barrier: 3 > 4
Fuel the Fire - Barrier 7 > 8
Gambit of Rage - Damage: 40 > 50
Gambit of Safety - Barrier: 35 > 40
Gambit of Safety - Self-inflict Blackflame: 3 > 1
Gambit of Strength - Might and Fortitude gain: 3 > 5
Graft Blackflame - Consume count: 2 > 3
Heat Fist - Flame Resist gain: 1 > 2
Melt Away - Damage: 13 > 15
Might From Suffering - Dice cost: Any Body > Any
Oppress the Wounded - Damage: 5 > 7
Pain Lash - Damage: 15 > 16
Pain Protects - Barrier per Burn: 6 > 7
Pain Transfer - Damage per Burn: 7 > 10
Pain Wall - Barrier: 9 > 10
Repeating Flame - Charge count: 1 > 2
Rising Flame - Permanent damage increase on Fatal: 2 > 3
Scorch - Burn inflicted: 1 > 2
Singeing Fist - Damage: 7 > 9
Spontaneous Ignition - Dice cost: Min 7 > Any Body + Any Body
Step Into Flame - Barrier: 12 > 13
Step Into Flame - Flame Resist gain on rune used: 3 > 4
Stoke the Blueflame - Dice cost: Exact 1 + Max 3 > Max 2 + Max 3
Vengeance - Damage: 25 > 35
Vengeance - Rarity change: Common > Uncommon
Thaumancer
\[Dev's Note: Thaumancer was actually right on target with a 21% win rate. So the goal of this update for Thaumancer is just to balance out their range of spells, as the win rate of the individual spells is still quite swingy. I've also noticed that Thaumancer still has the most undiscovered powerful synergies based on the win rates of spells I know for a fact are very strong, but the win rate shows them as quite low (or 0%, in one instance). Keep exploring!]
Avalanche - Dice cost: Even > Any
Bitter Cold - Dice cost: Max 2 > Exact 2 \[This was supposed to happen last update, but it looks like it didn't. Whoops.]
Blizzard - Dice cost: Max 2 + Max 2 > Exact 1 + Exact 1
Blood Cloud - Dice cost: Max 3 > Max 4
Calm Before the Storm - Barrier: 2 > 3
Calm Before the Storm - Charge count: 3 > 2
Chaos Bolt - Charge count: 7 > 9
Cold Front - Frost Barrier: 5 > 3
Crashing Wave - Temporary Might gain: 3 > 4
Electron Barrier - Charge steal barrier multiplier: 6x > 8x
Energy Field - Status gain: 4 > 3
Energy Pulse - Status gain: 6 > 5
Feel the Surge - Damage 19 > 21
Flurry - Consume count: 2 > 3
Frostbite Armor - Barrier: 25 > 30
Hailstorm - Damage: 3x DV > 4x DV
Hurricane Fist - Damage: 5x DV > 6x DV
Multibolt - Damage: 2x Storm > 3x Storm
Precipitation - Barrier: 3 > 4
Precipitation - Charge count: 2 > 1
Rapid Chilling - Barrier: 13 > 12
Rime Cycle - Dice cost: Min 7 + Any Rune > Any + Any Rune
Rolling Shock - Self-damage: 4 > 5
Rune Storm - Storm gain: 6 > 7
Snowball - Charge count: 3 > 2
Snow Pile - Frost Barrier: 7 > 6
Snow Pile - Cloud Seeding gain: 1 > 2
Snow Plating - Charge count: 4 > 3
Static - Dice cost: Countdown 7 > Countdown 10
Storm God's Fury - Damage: 175 > 200
Strike Twice - Damage: 9 > 10
Tempest - Damage: 10x Storm > 12x Storm
Thunderhead - Charge count: 1 > 2
Void Engine - Consume count: 4 > 3
Voltage Transfer - Damage: 16 > 15
Voltaic Shield - Barrier: 8 > 9
Voltaic Spear - Damage: 10 > 11
Volt Injection - Consume count: 3 > 2
Wall of Blizzard - Dice cost: Max 2 > Max 3
Winter's Boon - Frost Barrier: 25 > 18
Closing Thoughts
It will probably be a while before I have enough data to do another balance update, but I also do feel the game will likely be in a good place after this update in base difficulty. Further updates will be looking more closely at Worthiness, not just in combat, but holistically as well. I also think the game will likely be in a good enough spot after this update to start working on the Challenge Mode content update, so I would look forward to that either in the next update, or the update after that (depending on the preliminary analytics). Until then, happy playing!
-Thomas, PolyGryph