Generals!
Being a team who values community feedback and insight, we were eager to bring thoughts on the game (particularly focused around Units and balancing) from you, our players direct to our esteemed designers, Richard Garfield and Skaff Elias.
The nature of balancing is a tricky affair at best, and with varying perspectives between the designers, the team and the community, a discussion around where the game stands in terms of balance, our philosophy, and how this shapes the game in future was an anticipated moment.
Well, both Richard and Skaff were absolutely thrilled to hear our players' thoughts and, in turn, share their own. With balance on the agenda, we settled down for a fireside chat to discuss how they see Vanguard Exiles in its current iteration, as well as their considerations for shaping its future.
Tinbeard: To kick off the conversation, I think there’s no better place to start than the foundation of every Squad…its Unlimited Units.
R & S: This may seem surprising, but our first thoughts were that the Unlimited Units were too balanced! There was certainly an expectation that they could be a little more out of balance as they are, and in future we will almost definitely create Factions where their balance is even more varied. Having said that, the varying balance of Unlimited Units is a design goal of the game, although not necessarily a critical goal for future Factions.
Tinbeard: Unlimited Units play such a key role to the game, so immediately I assume differences in balance would be prioritised. Are there other elements surrounding this that factor into why it isn’t an immediate concern?
R & S: When we started thinking about games that have unique decks as part of gameplay (and when Richard first created Keyforge), we knew the critical factor would be how the Factions balanced as a whole with the others. Working within that constraint (more on that later) we want the Factions to specialize in different things, which means that we don’t want every Faction’s Units to be balanced at every cost level. In practice, that then means Unlimited Units need to possess some level of imbalance to align with the ethos that each Faction plays and feels different. Of course, whilst in Early Access, we are yet to know enough to make them wildly different from each other, but that is certainly the plan to come in future. We want the Factions as a whole to be balanced, especially with the consideration of the Faction combinations.
Tinbeard: Ah! That certainly adds more dots connecting to a bigger picture. But on the note of balancing entire Factions, this sounds like no small undertaking. Is there a long-term vision or plan around what this entails?
R & S: What do we mean when we say that we want the Factions to be ‘balanced’? That question is deeper than most realise. One of the main explanations behind this question is that players can’t automatically dismiss the merits of a deck purely by its Factions/Faction combination. Of course some Factions combinations will have an elevated perceived value, and likely be seen as higher tier competitive decks. What does this mean for us as designers? We have a lot of leeway to work with, but extracting the right data needed to iterate will be challenging and potentially confusing. Analogously to Magic: The Gathering, we don’t really expect or even WANT the various Factions to be consistently balanced on a perfect equilibrium, regardless of what defines that equilibrium. Magic: The Gathering is a great example of this. The various colours go through periods of being stronger or weaker relative to each other, relative to the format being played, and relative to the experience/skill level of the player. In time, ideally we’d see some Faction combinations fall in or out of popularity akin to this. We’d love to see some Faction/Unit combinations perform well in the specific types of Map Modifiers we've already implemented, where some perform better in low gold scenarios as opposed to others that excel in high gold scenarios. This is in part why balancing the Factions through their Unlimited Units works at cross purposes towards our eventual goal.
Tinbeard: This sounds like you have some exciting ideas on the road ahead. Any chance you could elaborate a little more on it?
R & S: We’d really like to eventually have seasons or a game mode that lean further into the map variations. For example, there are extra flooded Zones on the map, a higher ratio of Zones added per skirmish, or where more gold is given on average. Due to players knowing this ahead of time, it offers them the opportunity to choose which decks they’d like to bring to that particular tournament, league or season. This richness in strategy truly excites us about the game. What's more, we love that the absence of deckbuilding encourages players to truly explore the depth of their individual decks (or, perhaps in the distant future, decks they might be able to trade for!) We want knowledge and tactics to evolve through gameplay and trial-and-error, as most games (outside of real-life sports) aren’t usually capable of that due to leaning into construction and/or theory-crafting as the deciding components of their strategy.
Tinbeard: So as you move forward, what will be the areas you’re keeping an eye on to stay the course?
R & S: This was always intended to be an ambitious project, with the hope that players would come to appreciate the game in its fullest expression through experiencing many different decks across many games. This doesn’t mean that analysis of particular aspects of the game isn’t important (e.g. the benefit of Unlimited Units in any Faction) as any analysis of the top or lower end Unit costs, or anything in-between, always contribute to strategic decisions. Whereas in terms of major revisions, statistics along the lines of “on average how decks with certain Minor Faction perform against other decks with a different minor Faction” would garner significant attention as to “why that is” and (if necessary) what can be done about it. The primary balance goal at the Faction level is to ensure players can’t make judgements based on Factions alone. So our inclination when addressing balance issues would be the creation of new maps or formats that strengthen the weaker aspects of certain Factions, or the introduction of new Units to address existing gameplay concerns.”
Upon wrapping up the chat, I asked if they had any parting thoughts to share, and I was met with a response that had me both surprised and heartened. It was not a statement of “who was right” or “who knew better”, but rather a humble and open ethos, that focused on how discussion between designers, developers and the community is the key element to the future of Vanguard Exiles…
“Moving forward, our aim is to build on more robust analysis, whether our own or that from our community, to foster further evaluation and discussion as a hallmark of how players think about the game.” - Richard Garfield and Skaff Elias